Fisher Island, Miami Beach, FL, USA

6,565 Property Listings

Fisher Island Market Analysis Q1 2026

Current Market Conditions
Fisher Island is in a class by itself with properties ranging from $5M to $50M+. The island's inaccessibility (ferry/helicopter only) creates the ultimate privacy and exclusivity, driving prices that have no correlation with mainland Miami markets.

Price Trends

Median Sale Price: $8,500,000 (up 18.7% YoY)
- Average Price per SqFt: $1,850
- Days on Market: 215 days (extremely slow due to limited buyer pool)
- Inventory: 2 active listings

Investment Performance
- 5-Year Appreciation: +92% (though starting from astronomical base)
- Rental Yields: 1.5-2.5% (essentially irrelevant at this price point)
- Occupancy Rate: 65% (seasonal/secondary homes)

Market Dynamics
- Only 65 total homes on entire island
- Turnover is extremely rare (2-3 sales per year)
- Buyer pool includes billionaires, celebrities, VIPs
- Completely separate from mainland market cycles